For decades, Car and Driver’s 10Best awards have served as the automotive industry’s ultimate stamp of approval. Since its inception in 1983, this prestigious list has celebrated vehicles that not only excel in performance and design but also offer exceptional value and practicality for the everyday driver. Unlike other accolades that might focus on luxury or raw speed, the 10Best list has consistently prioritized accessibility, ensuring that the cars recognized are attainable dreams for a broad spectrum of consumers. Over the years, many vehicles have graced this coveted list, some for fleeting moments, while others have become enduring legends, demonstrating remarkable consistency and relevance across multiple generations. Today, we delve into the archives to explore the nine automotive icons that have earned the Car and Driver 10Best award an extraordinary number of times, showcasing their enduring appeal and engineering prowess.
The Pillars of Automotive Excellence: Cars with Multiple 10Best Wins
The quest for automotive perfection is a continuous journey, and certain vehicles have proven time and again that they possess the qualities necessary to stand out from the crowd. These aren’t just cars; they are automotive benchmarks that have consistently met and exceeded the rigorous standards set by the seasoned editors at Car and Driver. Their repeated appearances on the 10Best list are a testament to their innovative spirit, unwavering reliability, and ability to evolve with changing times and consumer demands.
Honda Prelude: A Decade of Driving Delight
Before the dawn of the modern era of performance coupes, the Honda Prelude carved out a significant niche for itself, earning a remarkable 10 wins on the prestigious Car and Driver 10Best list. Introduced in 1979, the Prelude was Honda’s answer to enthusiasts seeking a more stylish and engaging driving experience than what the ubiquitous Civic offered. While the Civic was the sensible choice for daily commutes, the Prelude was designed to stir the soul, boasting a sportier design and a focus on driving dynamics.
The Prelude’s tenure on the 10Best list spanned from 1984 to 1986 and then again from 1992 to 1998. This impressive run highlights the car’s ability to adapt and remain competitive across different generations and evolving automotive landscapes. Car and Driver consistently lauded the Prelude for its exceptional handling and well-rounded performance. A particularly glowing review from 1985 highlighted its prowess, stating it was “the best handling imported car money could buy,” a remarkable endorsement that placed it in the same conversation as significantly more expensive performance machines like the Porsche 944. This comparison underscored the Prelude’s extraordinary value proposition, offering a driving experience that punched well above its price point.
The 1993 model year marked a significant technological leap for the Prelude with the introduction of Honda’s VTEC (Variable Valve Timing and Lift Electronic Control) engine. This innovative technology allowed the engine to deliver robust power across a wider rev range, significantly enhancing its performance and responsiveness. This addition further solidified the Prelude’s reputation as a driver’s car, providing exhilarating acceleration and a more engaging connection between the driver and the machine. While the Prelude was discontinued in 2002, its legacy of performance, style, and consistent quality on the 10Best list remains a celebrated chapter in automotive history. The recent announcement of a new Prelude model has ignited excitement among enthusiasts, with many eager to see if the new iteration can live up to the legendary status of its predecessors.
Honda Civic: The Quintessential All-Rounder
The Honda Civic, arguably one of the most iconic and enduring names in automotive history, has also been a perennial favorite of Car and Driver’s 10Best awards, accumulating an impressive 11 victories. While the Prelude was designed to offer a sportier alternative, the Civic itself has consistently embodied the core principles of the 10Best list: affordability, reliability, and an uncompromised driving experience. Since its debut in 1972, the Civic emerged as a direct response to the global oil crisis, offering remarkable fuel efficiency at a time when gasoline prices were a significant concern for consumers. Its success was so profound that it has transcended numerous generations, each bringing its own advancements while retaining its fundamental appeal.
The Civic first earned its place on the 10Best list in 1985, where it was celebrated for its “jack of all trades” personality. It offered buyers a package that seamlessly blended practicality for daily life with an enjoyable driving experience and budget-friendly running costs. In 1988, another win further cemented its status, with the magazine commending its unwavering commitment to its core mission, coupled with substantial upgrades to its chassis and interior space. While the Civic experienced a slight dip in its 10Best streak during the early 2000s and 2010s, it made a triumphant return in 2018, particularly with the introduction of its sportier Si and high-performance Type R variants. Car and Driver was effusive in its praise for this resurgence, going as far as to declare the Civic Si “quite possibly the highest performing and most satisfying front-wheel-drive car on the market.” This resurgence demonstrated the Civic’s remarkable adaptability and its ability to re-establish its credentials as a benchmark for sporty, front-wheel-drive vehicles.
Ford Mustang: The American Pony Car Icon
Few automotive nameplates evoke as much cultural resonance and enduring appeal as the Ford Mustang. Debuting in 1964, the Mustang has been a cornerstone of Ford’s lineup for over six decades and seven distinct generations, cementing its status as the originator of the beloved “pony car” segment. The Mustang isn’t just a car; it’s a symbol of American automotive heritage, often mentioned in the same breath as rock and roll, baseball, and apple pie. Its enduring popularity is reflected in its impressive 11 wins on the Car and Driver 10Best list.
The Mustang holds the distinction of being one of the few American cars to have achieved such a high number of 10Best accolades, standing second only to a rival that will be mentioned later. It was also among the inaugural recipients in Car and Driver’s very first 10Best competition in 1983, signaling its immediate impact and lasting appeal. Like the Hondas that have also dominated the list, the Mustang’s success can be attributed to its unwavering clarity of purpose: to deliver an exhilarating driving experience that brings a smile to everyone who encounters it. Each generation of the Mustang has consistently hit this mark, blending performance enhancements with evolutionary styling. Ford has further bolstered its competitive edge by introducing iconic special editions such as the Shelby GT350 and the potent GT500, ensuring the Mustang remains a formidable contender on both the road and the racetrack.
Volkswagen Golf: The People’s Car Reimagined
The Volkswagen Golf, much like the Ford Mustang is to Ford, is a defining model for its manufacturer, but in a vastly different automotive philosophy. While the Mustang embodies the spirit of the muscle car, the Golf represents the pinnacle of the accessible, practical, and engaging hatchback. Introduced in 1974, the Golf was conceived to offer European consumers a refreshing alternative in a market often dominated by larger, less fuel-efficient vehicles. Its innovative front-wheel-drive layout and compact yet versatile design quickly set it apart, making it a global phenomenon and a consistent contender for automotive accolades.
The Golf’s journey on the Car and Driver 10Best list is a testament to its remarkable adaptability and its ability to consistently reinvent itself while staying true to its core values. Across numerous generations, the Golf has been lauded for its sophisticated engineering, refined driving dynamics, and exceptional build quality, often punching above its weight class in terms of perceived luxury and performance. Specific mentions often highlight its well-balanced chassis, responsive steering, and comfortable ride, making it a joy to drive in a variety of conditions. The introduction of the GTI variant, in particular, elevated the Golf’s status by injecting genuine performance into the practical hatchback formula, effectively creating the “hot hatch” segment and earning further acclaim from critics and consumers alike. The Golf’s consistent presence on the 10Best list underscores Volkswagen’s commitment to delivering a compelling package that appeals to a broad audience, blending everyday usability with an engaging driving experience that few can match.
BMW 3 Series: The Benchmark for Driving Dynamics
When discussions turn to the ultimate driver’s cars, the BMW 3 Series invariably emerges at the forefront. This iconic German sedan has not only defined the compact luxury sport sedan segment but has also consistently earned its place on the prestigious Car and Driver 10Best list an astonishing 17 times. This remarkable achievement speaks volumes about the 3 Series’ enduring appeal and its ability to set benchmarks for performance, handling, and driver engagement across generations.
From its inception, the 3 Series was engineered with a singular focus: to provide an unparalleled driving experience. Car and Driver has repeatedly praised its near-perfect weight distribution, its telepathic steering, and its potent yet refined powertrains. The car’s ability to balance exhilarating performance with everyday usability has been a key factor in its sustained success. Whether cruising on the highway or carving through winding country roads, the 3 Series has consistently delivered a connected and engaging driving experience that few rivals can replicate. Its reputation for agility and responsiveness has made it a favorite among driving enthusiasts and a benchmark against which all other cars in its class are measured. The 3 Series has also evolved with the times, incorporating advanced technology and safety features while maintaining its core driving DNA. This commitment to both innovation and tradition has allowed it to remain relevant and highly desirable for decades, solidifying its position as one of the most awarded vehicles in automotive history.
Mazda MX-5 Miata: The Purest Form of Driving Joy
In a world increasingly dominated by SUVs and performance-oriented machines, the Mazda MX-5 Miata stands as a beacon of pure, unadulterated driving pleasure. This lightweight, rear-wheel-drive roadster has captured the hearts of driving enthusiasts worldwide and has earned an impressive 13 wins on the Car and Driver 10Best list. Its enduring popularity is a testament to its simple yet brilliant formula: a focus on lightweight construction, balanced handling, and an affordable price tag.
The Miata’s philosophy is rooted in the concept of “jinba ittai,” a Japanese term that translates to “rider and horse as one.” This principle emphasizes the seamless connection between the driver and the machine, and the Miata embodies this perfectly. Car and Driver has consistently lauded its razor-sharp steering, its nimble chassis, and its rev-happy engine, which combine to create an incredibly engaging and fun driving experience. The Miata isn’t about raw power; it’s about the joy of the drive itself. Its compact size and exceptional agility allow it to dance through corners with a grace and precision that few other cars can match. Furthermore, its affordability and reliability have made it an accessible dream for a wide range of automotive enthusiasts. Each generation of the Miata has refined this winning formula, adding modern amenities and safety features without compromising its core ethos. The Mazda MX-5 Miata is more than just a sports car; it’s a celebration of the pure, simple joy of driving, and its consistent recognition on the 10Best list is a well-deserved honor.
Porsche 911: The Enduring Sports Car Icon
When it comes to iconic sports cars, the Porsche 911 stands in a class of its own. For over half a century, this legendary German machine has been the benchmark for performance, engineering, and design in the sports car world. Its unparalleled success is evident in its remarkable 23 wins on the Car and Driver 10Best list, more than any other vehicle on this esteemed roster. The 911 is not just a car; it’s an automotive institution, a dream machine that has consistently pushed the boundaries of what’s possible.
The Porsche 911’s longevity and consistent excellence can be attributed to its unwavering commitment to its core principles, coupled with a relentless pursuit of innovation. Car and Driver has consistently lauded its distinctive rear-engine layout, which contributes to its unique handling characteristics and its ability to deliver exhilarating acceleration. The 911’s blend of raw performance, exquisite craftsmanship, and everyday usability has made it a perennial favorite for decades. Whether navigating city streets or dominating the racetrack, the 911 delivers a driving experience that is both thrilling and refined. Porsche has masterfully evolved the 911 over the years, incorporating cutting-edge technology and aerodynamics while preserving its unmistakable silhouette and iconic character. The various models, from the Carrera to the Turbo and the GT variants, offer a spectrum of performance to cater to every enthusiast’s desire. The Porsche 911’s consistent presence on the 10Best list is a testament to its timeless appeal and its status as arguably the greatest sports car ever made.
BMW M3: The Ultimate Performance Sedan
The BMW M3 has long been the gold standard for performance sedans, offering an exhilarating blend of track-ready power and everyday practicality. This legendary M-division creation has consistently found its way onto Car and Driver’s coveted 10Best list, earning a remarkable 17 awards. The M3 represents the pinnacle of BMW’s engineering prowess, translating their racing heritage into a road-legal machine that excites and inspires.
Car and Driver’s praise for the M3 often centers on its potent inline-six engines, renowned for their smooth power delivery and impressive torque. However, it’s the M3’s chassis and suspension tuning that truly set it apart. The engineers at BMW M have perfected the art of creating a car that can tackle tight corners with precision and confidence while remaining comfortable enough for daily commuting. The steering feel is often described as telepathic, providing drivers with a direct connection to the road. Over the years, the M3 has evolved significantly, adapting to new technologies and emissions standards without compromising its core performance ethos. From its iconic E30 predecessor to the latest iterations, each M3 has pushed the boundaries of what a compact luxury performance sedan can achieve. Its ability to blend the practicality of a sedan with the heart and soul of a race car has cemented its status as a perennial favorite among automotive journalists and driving enthusiasts alike, making its repeated inclusion on the 10Best list well-deserved.
Mercedes-Benz C-Class: The Epitome of Refined Performance
The Mercedes-Benz C-Class has consistently exemplified the perfect marriage of luxury, comfort, and performance, earning it a distinguished 14 appearances on Car and Driver’s 10Best list. This compact executive car from the German marque has long been a benchmark for refinement and sophisticated driving dynamics, offering an elevated experience for a broad range of drivers.
Car and Driver’s editorial team has frequently lauded the C-Class for its impeccably crafted interior, its serene ride quality, and its powerful yet smooth powertrain options. The engineering behind the C-Class is designed to provide a feeling of effortless capability, whether navigating urban landscapes or embarking on longer journeys. Mercedes-Benz has consistently infused the C-Class with advanced technology and safety features, further enhancing its appeal as a comprehensive luxury package. The availability of various performance-oriented AMG variants has also broadened its appeal, offering even more potent acceleration and sharper handling for those seeking a more exhilarating drive. This ability to cater to diverse preferences—from ultimate comfort to spirited performance—has been key to the C-Class’s enduring success. Its consistent presence on the 10Best list is a testament to Mercedes-Benz’s commitment to delivering a vehicle that excels in multiple facets, setting a high standard for its segment year after year.
The Criteria for Enduring Success on the 10Best List
Achieving a single win on Car and Driver’s 10Best list is a significant accomplishment, but to do so multiple times requires a special blend of attributes that stand the test of time. The cars that consistently make this prestigious list share a common DNA, characterized by:
- Exceptional Driving Dynamics: Whether it’s precise steering, a well-balanced chassis, or responsive braking, these cars offer an engaging and confidence-inspiring driving experience.
- Compelling Performance: This doesn’t always mean raw horsepower, but rather a powertrain that delivers power smoothly and effectively, providing ample acceleration for merging, passing, and spirited driving.
- Practicality and Usability: The 10Best list prioritizes cars that are viable for everyday life. This includes considerations for cargo space, passenger comfort, fuel efficiency, and overall ease of use.
- Value for Money: While not necessarily the cheapest cars, these vehicles offer an outstanding return on investment, providing a high level of quality, performance, and features for their price point.
- Innovation and Evolution: The ability to adapt to changing technologies, consumer preferences, and regulatory environments is crucial. These cars consistently improve and innovate with each new generation.
- Reliability and Durability: A car that frequently breaks down or requires costly repairs won’t be a long-term favorite. Consistent reliability is a silent but critical factor.
Frequently Asked Questions About Car and Driver’s 10Best Awards
Q1: What are the main criteria Car and Driver uses for its 10Best list?
A1: Car and Driver’s 10Best awards prioritize vehicles that offer an outstanding combination of performance, handling, technology, fuel efficiency, safety, and overall value. The key is to identify cars that are exceptionally enjoyable to drive and offer a superior ownership experience for their intended purpose and price point. Affordability to the everyday consumer is a crucial, though not explicitly quantifiable, element.
Q2: Are there specific categories for the 10Best list?
A2: Historically, the 10Best list was more general, but as the automotive market has diversified, Car and Driver has sometimes introduced variations or focused on specific segments. However, the core 10Best list typically focuses on vehicles that are new or have been significantly updated for that model year, allowing for fresh comparisons across the market. Luxury and exotic vehicles above a certain price threshold are generally excluded to maintain the focus on attainable excellence.
Q3: How does Car and Driver test the vehicles for the 10Best list?
A3: The testing process is extensive and involves rigorous evaluation by a team of experienced automotive journalists and test drivers. They conduct extensive track testing (acceleration, braking, handling) and real-world driving on various road conditions. Vehicles are evaluated on a wide range of metrics, including driving dynamics, comfort, practicality, technology, safety, and value.
Q4: Can a car win the 10Best award multiple times?
A4: Absolutely! As this article demonstrates, many cars have achieved multiple wins. This signifies their enduring engineering quality, their ability to evolve with each new generation, and their consistent appeal to the discerning evaluators at Car and Driver.
Q5: What is the significance of the Porsche 911 having the most 10Best wins?
A5: The Porsche 911’s record-breaking 23 wins highlight its unparalleled consistency as a performance benchmark. It signifies the car’s ability to continually innovate and excel in the highly competitive sports car segment for decades, solidifying its status as an automotive legend and the epitome of sports car engineering.
Conclusion: A Legacy of Excellence
The cars that have consistently graced Car and Driver’s 10Best list are more than just automobiles; they are testaments to automotive engineering at its finest. Their repeated accolades underscore a dedication to driving pleasure, practical innovation, and exceptional value. From the sporty prowess of the Honda Prelude and Mazda Miata to the refined luxury of the Mercedes-Benz C-Class and the performance pedigree of the BMW 3 Series and M3, these vehicles have not only met but consistently exceeded expectations. The enduring legacy of the Ford Mustang and Volkswagen Golf as automotive icons, and the undeniable supremacy of the Porsche 911, further illustrate what it takes to achieve lasting automotive greatness. As the automotive landscape continues to evolve, these legendary models, and perhaps new contenders, will undoubtedly continue to vie for a spot on this prestigious list, inspiring drivers and shaping the future of the automobile.
Leave a Comment